Before delving into yet another Quaker world, I thought I would post a little here about my experience at North West Yearly Meeting. While I was there, many Friends asked me for some reflections about what I thought about their Yearly Meeting. It is interesting to be asked that question - as someone who has never experienced an Evangelical gathering before, and someone who was there because it was God's will with little other plans than to build relationships - because, really, what can I say? I have little to compare it to ... But even as I type that, I am sure comparison is not what is needed. We do too much of that already in the Quaker world. While I know there is much more that will come to the surface as the experience digests, I thought I would share some of my observations and thoughts (for what they are worth) now.
First of all, I was delighted at the warmth and excitement that greeted Andrew and me. I don't know what I was expecting but it certainly wasn't for people to continue to come up to us and thank us for coming, to tell us how excited they were that we were there, to begin conversations in the auditoriums, dining halls, hallways, bathrooms ... I was so overcome by fear before getting to NWYM (made up entirely of overly dramatic visualizations of being judged and shunned), that I was floating on a cloud for the entire time when I realized deep within myself what I had known to be true all along: we are all Friends.
The other thing that I was surprised by was how liberal the Yearly Meeting was. I don't know what I was thinking going into it, but being someone who doesn't identify as Christian, but as a Follower of Jesus, I was worried that I would not be accepted for who I was. How wrong I was. There was no one who questioned my own validity as a Quaker or insinuated that I was somehow "less than" because of my spiritual identification. Friends were happy to engage in dialog with me, and I found myself entering into mutual vulnerable covenants often, where I felt safe to be open and be myself, and know that I would be loved for it.
Perhaps that was one of the most striking pieces to me: the love within the community. I felt like I was embraced, as a sister, as a Friend, as a member of this powerful spiritual community. What a humbling and honoring experience it was!
There were other more specific things I noticed. For one, I was very aware of the restructuring of the Yearly Meeting body right now (reorganizing of Boards - which are similar to liberal "Committees" and the staff of the Yearly Meeting). Because of the restructuring and the deep wrestling that the community has been doing corporately over the past couple of years, the movement within the YM is apparent to the naked eye. People are inspired, and there is energy to be doing God's Work in the world.
Another thing that went along with that is the presence of recognition of service ... Time and again, I was touched to see various people acknowledged, thanked and recognized for their work within the community and the gifts that they bring. It was not done stintingly or jealously ... But with deep gratitude and appreciation - and it was accepted with humble and honest appreciation for having been recognized. It takes work to do God's Will in the world, and this Yearly Meeting seemed to understand that we are only building stronger community and inspiring more people to do that work when they are honored for it ...
The quality of corporate worship was made so much richer and deeper with song. The services were amazing and the songs were a piece of the worship that I will deeply miss. To join voices with others in the gathering, in vocal prayer and praise, was something that I will always remember. It moved me in ways that I have not been moved in a long time - and made my chest feel close to bursting on more than one occasion.
The plenaries from every night spoke to me in a way that I never imagined. The questions that I didn't know I had been asking were answered. Something that was very apparent to me during my time there was that God is certainly moving Friends forward together. Pieces of each of the messages that were given were pieces that Andrew and I have known we needed to be bringing to Philadelphia Yearly Meeting this year. How incredibly powerful to hear the message you have received from God to deliver to one body of Friends be delivered a week prior to another body of Friends. And to have each of those bodies of Friends be considered very different from each other. We have so much more in common than we think we do.
The last thought I have for the night is the power of intervisitation. I learned more this last couple of days - and was spoken to in a way that I didn't imagine was possible prior to this gathering. Friends, the movement within our society is clear - to find Way Forward together. We are all Friends, and we each have important lessons to learn from one another. But the first step is perhaps the most important. To build relationships across the theological divides and truly become a family in the name of the Divine. We can heal the pain we experience through disconnection throughout the wider society - but first, we must work on healing that pain within our Society. Take the time to fall in love with one another in God. It's perhaps one of the greatest gifts you can give or be given.
Blessings be with you, dear Friends.
First of all, I was delighted at the warmth and excitement that greeted Andrew and me. I don't know what I was expecting but it certainly wasn't for people to continue to come up to us and thank us for coming, to tell us how excited they were that we were there, to begin conversations in the auditoriums, dining halls, hallways, bathrooms ... I was so overcome by fear before getting to NWYM (made up entirely of overly dramatic visualizations of being judged and shunned), that I was floating on a cloud for the entire time when I realized deep within myself what I had known to be true all along: we are all Friends.
The other thing that I was surprised by was how liberal the Yearly Meeting was. I don't know what I was thinking going into it, but being someone who doesn't identify as Christian, but as a Follower of Jesus, I was worried that I would not be accepted for who I was. How wrong I was. There was no one who questioned my own validity as a Quaker or insinuated that I was somehow "less than" because of my spiritual identification. Friends were happy to engage in dialog with me, and I found myself entering into mutual vulnerable covenants often, where I felt safe to be open and be myself, and know that I would be loved for it.
Perhaps that was one of the most striking pieces to me: the love within the community. I felt like I was embraced, as a sister, as a Friend, as a member of this powerful spiritual community. What a humbling and honoring experience it was!
There were other more specific things I noticed. For one, I was very aware of the restructuring of the Yearly Meeting body right now (reorganizing of Boards - which are similar to liberal "Committees" and the staff of the Yearly Meeting). Because of the restructuring and the deep wrestling that the community has been doing corporately over the past couple of years, the movement within the YM is apparent to the naked eye. People are inspired, and there is energy to be doing God's Work in the world.
Another thing that went along with that is the presence of recognition of service ... Time and again, I was touched to see various people acknowledged, thanked and recognized for their work within the community and the gifts that they bring. It was not done stintingly or jealously ... But with deep gratitude and appreciation - and it was accepted with humble and honest appreciation for having been recognized. It takes work to do God's Will in the world, and this Yearly Meeting seemed to understand that we are only building stronger community and inspiring more people to do that work when they are honored for it ...
The quality of corporate worship was made so much richer and deeper with song. The services were amazing and the songs were a piece of the worship that I will deeply miss. To join voices with others in the gathering, in vocal prayer and praise, was something that I will always remember. It moved me in ways that I have not been moved in a long time - and made my chest feel close to bursting on more than one occasion.
The plenaries from every night spoke to me in a way that I never imagined. The questions that I didn't know I had been asking were answered. Something that was very apparent to me during my time there was that God is certainly moving Friends forward together. Pieces of each of the messages that were given were pieces that Andrew and I have known we needed to be bringing to Philadelphia Yearly Meeting this year. How incredibly powerful to hear the message you have received from God to deliver to one body of Friends be delivered a week prior to another body of Friends. And to have each of those bodies of Friends be considered very different from each other. We have so much more in common than we think we do.
The last thought I have for the night is the power of intervisitation. I learned more this last couple of days - and was spoken to in a way that I didn't imagine was possible prior to this gathering. Friends, the movement within our society is clear - to find Way Forward together. We are all Friends, and we each have important lessons to learn from one another. But the first step is perhaps the most important. To build relationships across the theological divides and truly become a family in the name of the Divine. We can heal the pain we experience through disconnection throughout the wider society - but first, we must work on healing that pain within our Society. Take the time to fall in love with one another in God. It's perhaps one of the greatest gifts you can give or be given.
Blessings be with you, dear Friends.
- Location:Philadelphia, PA


Comments
And I'm not as opposed to inter-branch dialogue as I once was, but I would still like to make one remark: I'm not sure "pain" is the relevant category.
Friends have separated into different branches and traditions for real reasons; they aren't just personal grudges over pride or affection in need of healing. There's some of that, but I'm not sure it's really that much -- after all, the people who saw the separations firsthand are mostly long dead.
But what does exist are real, deep difference in theological or philosophical beliefs. I think it's possible to overcome them, and it's probably worthwhile for some to keep trying. But this isn't so much a matter of healing pain as coming to unity about the nature of the world. Until those differences are resolved, artificial unity (e.g. by liberal Friends maintaining ties to FUM) seems just that. As Amos said, "How can two walk together except they be agreed?"
I hope I don't sound too cantankerous; I just think these are questions that should be wrestled with. Look forward to meeting you at CYM.
Zach Alexander / The Seed Lifting Up
You don't sound cantankerous ... You sound like you are wrestling, much like I am and so many others I know.
I agree with you that the divisions that exist are *real* divisions - that are based on differences in theological belief and practice. However, I don't believe the divisions that happened in the first place purely had to do with these differences. From the information I have read (and with a definite danger in over-simplifying) I understand that personality differences, influences from the "outside world" and theological differences were all at play.
As for healing of the divisions, I think that I am often misunderstood in this place. I don't mean to say that all Friends must get to a place where they believe the same thing ... But I think that the healing work that needs to be done within our Society has much more to do with delving deeply into the history of de-valuing and "Other-izing" Quakers that we don't understand or identify with. The healing I envision has to do with building deep, trusting relationships with those we would normally believe we were "different" from - and moving forward, truly as F/friends.
In reading Claire's response to you, I guess I would have to simply say "Friend speaks my mind."
Looking forward to meeting/seeing you at CYM.
Blessings.
Erin
I had a better experience than I did last year at my area EFI YM which I've posted about on my blog lovinlifeliz.blogspot.com
Love,
Liz
Right now I want to respond to Zach, though. (Hi Zach.) First of all, yes, Friends did separate for real reasons, I agree. (Just look at how radically different we all are today!) Where I disagree with you is about the need for healing. Healing our wounds from the splits is not about reuniting back into one "branch". It’s not about coming to a single agreement about how we should worship and what the “right” theological approach is. Clearly we differ dramatically.
However, just because there were real reasons for splitting does not mean that everything went smoothly and in good conscience. Large bodies of Friends didn't just come together and reach unity about the need to go in different directions. Often it was more like one group of Friends differed within another, and when unity was NOT reached, this differing group left and started their own meeting(s) or yearly meeting(s), claiming that they were in fact the ones with real Truth and that the others were off track. Though these Friends have probably all passed by now as you mentioned, they set the foundations for where we are today. There continues to be a great deal of animosity, suspicion, and finger-pointing among the different traditions of Friends, which is indeed painful and stems from the original wounds caused by the split. We continue to point fingers at one another and make claims such as, "You're not really Quaker, we over here have it right, we're the real Quakers!" Healing is not just about our theological differences, it's about maturity, patience, and a willingness to engage with those we see as "other".
You're right that there are real, deep differences in theological and/or philosophical beliefs. That's part of the beauty of it all. We all have so much to learn from each other in our diversity, if only from the process of overcoming our own suspicion and judgment of one another.
I’ll be back up near Boston by September – we should meet up again then.
Much love to all,
Claire
http://godthat.blogspot.com
It is wonderful to hear about your time with NWYM. I've been following your travels and am so thankful that you are being faithful to your leadings.
Don't worry if you can't write about everything because the point is to be present, not necessarily to explain your experiences to others. What God wants you to say will get said, of that I'm sure!
Blessings to you, and I look forward to your return to Richmond.
Cathy Habschmidt
It was so great to get to meet you at NWYM. I'm glad you had a good experience. I'd welcome any feedback that wasn't so positive, too--we'd love to learn from the perspective of someone coming in from the "outside." I hope we meet again sometime soon-ish!
~Cherice
I know that it's a bit late to be posting here now, but for a week now I've really been wanting to join my voice to the others here, and only just now had the time.
Thank you so much, Erin, for paying attention to where God is leading you, and for taking up this ministry of communication and sharing, and possibly, healing. This post really helps me understand Quakers different from my own personal variety much better.
And, while I appreciate and understand Zach's comments, and think there is much wisdom in them (as there always is to Zach's comments!), I want to join you and Claire (hi, Claire, if you're still reading this!) in pointing out that listening to others and appreciating them -- and even "converging" with them in some ways -- does NOT require that we all have to believe the same things, or think precisely in the same ways. It simply means that we are aware of each other, and learn from each others' strengths, and share in that strength through an expanded community.
I don't think it is tragic that Quakers split -- perhaps by focusing each on different approaches to spiritual matters, we each achieve greater depth -- but I do think that something was lost when we each lost track of each other and what each branch of Quakerism represented. I have no urge to merge with, say, the EFI -- but that does not mean I cannot learn from my Evangelical brothers and sisters what has been lost in my own Conservative and Liberal traditions.